Conflicting Discourses: Understanding the Rejection of a Swiss National Park Project Using Data Analysis Triangulation
Resource type
Journal Article
Status
Published
Recommended form of citation (APA)
Michel, A. H., & Bruggmann, A. (2019). Conflicting discourses: understanding the rejection of a Swiss national park project using data analysis triangulation. Mountain Research and Development, 39(1), R24-R36. https://doi.org/10.1659/MRD-JOURNAL-D-18-00081.1
Author(s)
Bruggmann, André
External DOI
PHSG Organisation name
Project(s)
License Condition
All rights reserved
Proforis OA-status
Green OA - published version
Topic PHSG
Räume, Zeiten, Gesellschaften (RZG)
Fields of Science and Technology (OECD)
Environmental sciences (social aspects)
Abstract
This article pursues 2 objectives: First, we show how a national park project in the Swiss Alps, Parc Adula, was addressed in contemporary neoliberal discourses on conservation and how these discourses influenced the rejection of the park. Second, we use triangulation to bridge the gap between 2 data analysis approaches, combining qualitative methods with the quantitative analytical tools of corpus linguistics. This allows an in-depth analysis of discourses surrounding and influencing national park planning. Furthermore, we outline challenges faced by conservation incentives based on discursive gaps and different uses of language in the arguments of government officials and residents affected by park negotiations. In the case of Parc Adula, these discursive gaps and language differences created distrust and made park planning difficult. This further reinforced a discursive disruption within and between neoliberal understandings of conservation and local discourses, eventually leading to the rejection of the national park project. This paper presents a novel analytical perspective on current conservation issues in Alpine areas and opens up ground for further research on communication practices, their local embeddedness, and their impacts on protected area establishment.
PHSG Organisation name
Project(s)
Version
Published Version
Access Rights
Open Access
License Condition
All rights reserved
Rights Holder
Publisher
Copyright-Statement
Usage of BioOne Digital Library content is strictly limited to personal, educational, and non-commmercial use. Commercial inquiries or rights and permissions requests should be directed to the individual publisher as copyright holder.